Connecticut Homeowners Shocked by Insurance Nonrenewals Tied to Roof Condition

Homeowners across Connecticut are facing a new and frustrating challenge: losing their homeowner's insurance coverage because of their roof condition. Even well-maintained homes are being flagged as “high risk” after insurers review aerial photos or remote roof inspections.

For many families, the news comes as a shock—one letter in the mail can mean scrambling to find replacement coverage or even facing higher premiums. Let’s break down why this is happening, what the rules are in Connecticut, and what you can do to protect your home and coverage.

Why Roof Condition Matters for Homeowners Insurance in Connecticut

Your roof is the first line of defense against New England’s unpredictable weather—snow, heavy rain, hail, and strong winds. Because it plays such a critical role, insurers weigh roof age and condition heavily when deciding whether to write or renew a policy.

• Older roofs = higher risk: Asphalt shingles typically last 15–20 years. Beyond that, the likelihood of leaks and claims rises sharply.

• Damage costs add up: A single roof claim can cost insurers tens of thousands of dollars, especially if water damage spreads inside the home.

• Preventive cancellations: Some insurers prefer to nonrenew a policy before damage occurs rather than take on the future risk.

The Rise of Aerial & Remote Roof Inspections

Traditionally, insurers relied on in-person inspections. Today, many companies use satellite imagery, drones, or aerial photographs to evaluate roof condition. While this technology is efficient, it has created new problems for homeowners.

• Overly strict interpretations: A roof that looks “discolored” from above may actually be sound when inspected in person.

• No chance to explain: Many homeowners only find out after receiving a nonrenewal notice.

• Accuracy concerns: Connecticut homeowners have reported being dropped despite having newer roofs or no history of roof-related claims.

This practice has sparked complaints and drawn the attention of regulators.

What Connecticut Regulators Are Saying

The Connecticut Insurance Department (CID) has acknowledged the growing number of complaints about roof-based nonrenewals.

• Insurers must provide written notice before canceling or nonrenewing a policy.

• Homeowners have the right to ask for inspection details and clarification.

• The CID has urged insurers to ensure that aerial images are accurate and fair.

For now, the practice remains legal—but state officials are keeping a close eye on how insurers apply these standards.

What To Do if Your Policy Is Nonrenewed Over Roof Condition

If you’ve received a nonrenewal notice tied to your roof, here’s how to respond:

1. Request the inspection report → Ask your insurer for the photos or documentation used.

2. Get a second opinion → Hire a licensed roof inspector to provide an independent evaluation.

3. Explore your options → Work with an independent insurance broker in Connecticut to shop multiple carriers. Not all insurers use the same roof requirements.

4. Consider repairs or replacement → If your roof is nearing the end of its life, investing in updates can restore your insurability and even reduce premiums.

How to Protect Your Home Insurance Coverage Before It’s Too Late

The best defense is a proactive approach:

• Keep maintenance records: Save receipts and photos of roof repairs or inspections.

• Schedule inspections every 2–3 years: Early detection prevents issues from worsening.

• Stay ahead of roof age cutoffs: If your roof is approaching 20 years old, start planning for replacement.

• Work with a local broker: Companies like Insure Connecticut LLC can connect you with insurers more flexible on roof requirements.

Key Takeaways for Connecticut Homeowners

• Roof age and condition are now among the top factors in coverage decisions.

• Aerial imagery is here to stay, but homeowners can challenge unfair assessments.

• Nonrenewal doesn’t mean you’re uninsurable—other carriers may accept your roof.

• Being proactive with documentation and maintenance is the best way to keep coverage affordable.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: Can my homeowner's insurance company cancel my policy because of my roof in Connecticut?

Yes. Insurers can choose not to renew policies if they determine your roof is too old or in poor condition, but they must provide written notice.

Q2: How old can my roof be before insurance becomes an issue?

Many insurers raise concerns around 15–20 years for asphalt shingle roofs. Some carriers won’t insure roofs older than 20 years without proof of recent replacement.

Q3: What happens if I can’t afford a roof replacement right away?

You may still be able to find coverage with certain insurers, though it may come with higher premiums. An independent broker can help locate options.

Q4: Are aerial roof inspections legal in Connecticut?

Yes. Insurers can use aerial or satellite images, but they must ensure accuracy and provide documentation if requested.

Q5: How can I find affordable homeowner's insurance if my policy is nonrenewed?

Work with a Connecticut-based insurance broker like Insure Connecticut LLC, who has access to multiple carriers and can help match you with an insurer willing to cover your home.

Protect Your Home and Coverage

Don’t wait until a surprise nonrenewal leaves you scrambling. At Insure Connecticut LLC, we help homeowners across Connecticut find coverage that works—even if your roof has raised red flags with other insurers.

📞 Call us today at (860) 970-0977 or request a free homeowners insurance quote to secure your peace of mind.